Fabula
S2E5 · Happy Valley S02E05

Alison executes Daryl to end his crimes

In a moment of brutal maternal desperation, Alison—confronted with the irreversible horror of her son Daryl’s serial killings—makes a final, irreversible choice. After Daryl tearfully confesses his crimes and begs for her help, Alison feigns a plan to escape the farm together, only to retrieve a shotgun and shoot him dead. The act is framed as a mercy killing, sparing him from public exposure, legal punishment, or the dark forces manipulating him. The gunshot echoes as a final, devastating punctuation to their fractured relationship, underscoring the moral decay of their world, where violence becomes the only language left to protect the innocent from the guilty. The event serves as a tragic climax to Alison’s arc, revealing the depths of her love and the lengths she will go to preserve what little remains of her son’s humanity—even if it means destroying him herself. The shot also functions as a narrative turning point, forcing the police investigation to confront a new layer of complexity: a killer who was already dead when the latest victim was found, suggesting deeper, unseen forces at play.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

The scene culminates in a gunshot, signifying Alison's desperate act to protect her son Daryl by ending his life and preventing the exposure of his crimes to the authorities.

tense anticipation to shocking resolution

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

2

A storm of grief, love, and desperation, masked by an eerie calm. She is resolute in her decision, but the weight of what she is about to do is palpable beneath her composed exterior.

Alison Garrs moves with cold precision, her maternal instincts twisted into a final act of mercy. She listens to Daryl’s confession with a steely resolve, her face betraying no emotion as she reassures him with a fabricated plan of escape. Her actions are methodical: she leaves the table, retrieves the old shotgun, and returns silently to press its barrel to the back of Daryl’s head. The act is swift and decisive, her grip steady despite the gravity of what she is about to do. Her voice remains calm and soothing, masking the horror of her intent until the very last moment.

Goals in this moment
  • To spare Daryl from the public exposure and legal punishment that would follow his crimes, believing it is the only way to protect what little remains of his humanity.
  • To end the cycle of violence and suffering that has consumed their lives, even if it means becoming a killer herself.
Active beliefs
  • That Daryl is beyond saving by any conventional means, and that her love for him demands she act decisively to end his suffering.
  • That the world would never understand or forgive Daryl, and that she must be the one to deliver justice—or mercy—instead.
Character traits
Resolute Desperate Grief-stricken Protective to the point of destruction Coldly pragmatic
Follow Alison Garrs's journey

Abject terror and remorse, tinged with a fragile hope that his mother can somehow fix everything. His emotional state is raw and exposed, stripped of his usual evasive detachment.

Daryl Garrs sits at the kitchen table, his body wracked with sobs as he confesses to his mother the full extent of his crimes. His hands tremble, and his voice cracks with remorse and terror. He begs Alison for help, clinging to the desperate hope that she can save him from the consequences of his actions. His emotional state is one of utter vulnerability, his usual detachment shattered by the weight of his guilt and the fear of what comes next.

Goals in this moment
  • To be saved from the consequences of his crimes, either through escape or Alison’s intervention.
  • To cling to the last vestiges of his mother’s love and protection, even as he knows he doesn’t deserve it.
Active beliefs
  • That Alison can and will protect him, no matter what he has done.
  • That he is beyond redemption but still deserves her love and mercy.
Character traits
Remorseful Desperate Terrified Vulnerable Childlike in his dependence on Alison
Follow Daryl Garrs's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

1
Alison's Execution Shotgun

Alison’s old shotgun is the instrument of Daryl’s death, symbolizing the violent and irreversible nature of her choice. The weapon is retrieved from another room in the farmhouse, its cold steel contrasting sharply with the warmth of the kitchen and the remnants of their shared meal. Alison presses the barrel to the back of Daryl’s head, her grip steady despite the gravity of the act. The shotgun is not just a tool of destruction but a metaphor for the moral decay that has consumed the Garrs family, as well as the lengths to which Alison will go to protect her son—even from himself.

Before: Stored in another room of Far Sunderland Farm, …
After: Discharged and discarded, its purpose fulfilled in the …
Before: Stored in another room of Far Sunderland Farm, likely cleaned and maintained but not in immediate use. It is a relic of the farm’s isolation and the Garrs’ self-reliance, symbolizing both protection and potential violence.
After: Discharged and discarded, its purpose fulfilled in the most tragic of ways. The shotgun lies where it fell after the shot, a silent witness to the irreversible act that has just taken place. Its presence now serves as a grim reminder of the violence that has unfolded.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What led here 1
Causal

"Daryl confirms he is the reason for the harm, which then culminates in a gunshot."

Daryl Confesses to Alison in the Night
S2E5 · Happy Valley S02E05

Part of Larger Arcs

Key Dialogue

"DARYL: "I didn’t mean to, Mum. I didn’t mean to do any of it. But I couldn’t stop. I couldn’t stop.""
"ALISON: "Shh. We’ll fix this. We’ll get away. Just you and me, like we always talked about. America. A fresh start.""
"ALISON: "I love you, Daryl. I always have. And I always will.""