Fabula
S2E6 · Happy Valley S02E06

Catherine confronts farmhouse carnage

Catherine Cawood and PC Shafiq Shah arrive at Far Sunderland Farm to discover a scene of brutal violence: Daryl Garrs lies dead from a shotgun wound to the back of his head, his body slumped across a blood-splattered table, while his mother, Alison, clings to life after a near-fatal overdose of alcohol and Diazepam. The kitchen is a grotesque tableau of violence—blood and brain matter coating the walls, ceiling, and door—indicating a murder-suicide attempt. Catherine immediately shifts into crisis mode, prioritizing Alison’s survival over preserving the crime scene. She radios for urgent medical and forensic support, directs Shaf to secure the scene, and attempts to extract information from Alison, who is barely conscious but visibly traumatized. The discovery forces Catherine into a high-stakes balancing act: stabilizing a dying woman while confronting the escalating brutality of Tommy Lee Royce’s influence. The scene underscores the fragility of those caught in Royce’s web and the moral compromises Catherine must make to protect the vulnerable, even as the investigation into Vicky Fleming’s murder takes a darker turn. The visceral horror of the farmhouse serves as a stark reminder of the human cost of Royce’s manipulations and the lengths to which his followers will go to fulfill his twisted desires.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Catherine and Shaf discover a gruesome scene: Daryl is dead from a shotgun wound, and Alison is barely alive from an apparent overdose. Catherine immediately assesses the situation and checks for Alison's pulse, recognizing the severity of the situation.

shock to urgent action

Catherine attempts to rouse Alison and determine her condition, while simultaneously directing Shaf to search the rest of the house. Catherine urgently radios for assistance, reporting the overdose and the fatal shooting, specifying the need for specialized units to secure the scene.

urgent to controlled

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

4

A fractured state between stupor and agony. She is physically and emotionally broken, her reactions visceral and wordless, her mind trapped in the horror of her actions. There is no coherence, only raw, animalistic grief and the ghost of her son’s presence.

Alison Garrs is found slumped at the kitchen table, her body barely responsive but her mind flickering with the horror of what she’s done. She’s streaked with tears, her eyes bloodshot, and her breathing shallow. When she sees Daryl’s body, she lets out a choked sob ('Oh—!'), her body convulsing as she tries—and fails—to flee the scene. Catherine and Shafiq drag her outside, her limbs limp, her mind trapped in a loop of grief and guilt. She is a shell of a person, her actions driven by instinct rather than coherence, a victim of her own desperate love and the violence it spawned.

Goals in this moment
  • Escape the immediate horror of the scene, even if her body won’t cooperate.
  • Somehow communicate what happened, though she lacks the words or clarity to do so.
Active beliefs
  • She has lost everything, and there is no going back from this.
  • Her son is dead because of her, and she deserves whatever comes next.
Character traits
Traumatized and barely conscious Physically incapacitated but emotionally raw Driven by instinctual reactions Overwhelmed by grief and guilt Unable to articulate her actions
Follow Alison Garrs's journey

A steely resolve masking deep horror and compassion. Surface-level, she is the picture of professionalism, but her internal turmoil is betrayed by rare moments of tenderness ('love') and dark humor ('Man up, Princess'), revealing the weight of the scene pressing against her usual stoicism.

Catherine Cawood stands in the center of the blood-drenched kitchen, her boots sticking slightly to the floor as she takes in the carnage with a sergeant’s trained eye. She immediately assesses Alison’s condition, feeling for a pulse with a firm but gentle hand, her voice steady despite the horror unfolding. Her movements are precise and deliberate: she radios for backup with clinical efficiency, directs Shafiq to secure the scene, and attempts to extract information from Alison, her questions sharp but laced with unexpected tenderness ('listen love'). When Alison reacts to Daryl’s body, Catherine acts swiftly to move her outside, defying protocol in a calculated risk to save her life. Her emotional state is a controlled storm—horrified by the violence but driven by the need to act, her compassion for Alison warring with her professional duty.

Goals in this moment
  • Stabilize Alison Garrs’ condition and save her life, prioritizing her survival over forensic integrity.
  • Secure the crime scene and ensure no additional threats or victims remain, balancing urgency with methodical assessment.
Active beliefs
  • Alison Garrs is the key to understanding what happened here, and her survival is critical to the investigation.
  • The scene is a direct result of Tommy Lee Royce’s manipulative influence, and every second counts in unraveling his web.
Character traits
Tactical under pressure Emotionally resilient yet vulnerable Darkly humorous in crisis Protective to a fault Clinical yet compassionate Defiant of protocol when morally necessary
Follow Catherine Cawood's journey
Supporting 2

Neutral and focused, channeling the urgency of the situation into actionable steps. There is no room for personal reaction—only the need to coordinate resources and ensure nothing is overlooked.

The Radio Dispatcher (Bravo November four-five) is heard only through Catherine’s radio, his voice calm and procedural as he logs the details of the emergency. He confirms receipt of Catherine’s urgent requests for medical, forensic, and police support, his tone betraying no emotion but ensuring the machinery of response is set in motion. His role is purely logistical, a disembodied voice in the chaos, yet his efficiency is the lifeline that will bring help to Far Sunderland Farm.

Goals in this moment
  • Log all details of the emergency accurately for the record.
  • Dispatch the necessary teams (ambulance, forensic, police) to the scene with minimal delay.
Active beliefs
  • Every second counts in emergencies, and protocol must be followed to the letter.
  • Catherine Cawood’s assessment of the scene is reliable, and her requests must be prioritized.
Character traits
Calm under pressure Procedurally efficient Emotionally detached (by necessity) Reliable in crisis A voice of institutional order
Follow Radio Dispatcher's journey

Overwhelmed and hesitant, teetering between professional duty and personal revulsion. His shock is palpable, but he channels it into action, his compliance with Catherine’s directives revealing a deep-seated respect for her authority even in the face of moral ambiguity.

Shafiq Shah enters the kitchen behind Catherine, his breath catching as he takes in the blood and gore. He hesitates, his grip tightening on his baton as Catherine barks orders at him. He complies reluctantly, heading upstairs to check for additional victims or threats, his movements stiff with unease. When he returns, he’s visibly shaken but follows Catherine’s lead in moving Alison outside, his initial resistance ('I thought you weren’t supposed to move [people]') giving way to dutiful action. His role is secondary but critical—he’s the reluctant counterpart to Catherine’s decisive leadership, his shock a foil to her resolve.

Goals in this moment
  • Follow Catherine’s instructions to the letter, ensuring the scene is secured and no threats remain.
  • Support Catherine in moving Alison Garrs to safety, despite his initial reluctance and the ethical dilemmas involved.
Active beliefs
  • Catherine Cawood knows what she’s doing, even if her methods bend the rules.
  • This scene is beyond anything he’s encountered before, and he’s out of his depth.
Character traits
Hesitant but dutiful Visibly shaken by violence Reluctant to defy protocol Quick to follow orders once committed Physically present but emotionally detached
Follow Shafiq Shah …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

7
Alison Garrs' Diazepam Packs

The 30 empty Diazepam blister packs are scattered in front of Alison like a confession, their absence a damning indictment of her intent. Each pack is devoid of pills, the foil torn open in haste, suggesting a frantic, almost mechanical consumption. Catherine notes them immediately, her fingers brushing against the packs as she checks Alison’s pulse. They are not just evidence—they are a narrative detail, a physical representation of Alison’s desperation to escape the reality of her actions. The packs will later be analyzed to confirm the dosage and type of medication, but in this moment, they are a visceral reminder of the lengths to which she went to end her life.

Before: Full, sealed, and stored in a cabinet or …
After: Collected as evidence, photographed in situ, and analyzed …
Before: Full, sealed, and stored in a cabinet or drawer. Alison retrieved them in a state of panic, tearing open the packs to consume all 30 pills in a short period.
After: Collected as evidence, photographed in situ, and analyzed to confirm the type and quantity of medication ingested. They become a critical piece of the toxicology report.
Alison Garrs' Overdose Evidence (Whisky Bottle and Diazepam Tablets)

The empty whisky bottle rests beside the vodka bottle and Diazepam packs, another piece of the puzzle in Alison’s overdose. Its presence suggests a methodical, almost ritualistic consumption—first the pills, then the alcohol to wash them down, then more alcohol to dull the edges of reality. The bottle is a silent witness to her descent into despair, its emptiness a metaphor for the void she sought to fill. Catherine’s gaze flicks over it as she takes in the scene, her mind already piecing together the timeline of Alison’s actions. It is a detail that will later be confirmed by toxicology reports, but in this moment, it is a chilling indicator of intent.

Before: Partially full when Alison began drinking, now empty …
After: Photographed, tagged, and collected as evidence. Its contents …
Before: Partially full when Alison began drinking, now empty and placed haphazardly on the table. It may have been used to chase the Diazepam, its contents consumed in a state of panic and grief.
After: Photographed, tagged, and collected as evidence. Its contents are analyzed to confirm the type and quantity of alcohol ingested, contributing to the forensic narrative of the overdose.
Alison Garrs' Overdose Evidence Vodka Bottle

The empty vodka bottle sits directly in front of Alison Garrs on the blood-splattered table, a grim companion to the whisky bottle and scattered Diazepam packs. It is a stark indicator of her overdose attempt—a desperate, failed escape from the horror of what she’s done. The bottle is likely smudged with her fingerprints, its contents consumed in a frenzied, alcohol-fueled stupor. Catherine notes it immediately, her eyes scanning the table as she assesses Alison’s condition. It is not just a clue but a narrative detail: the bottle represents Alison’s final, futile attempt to numb the pain of her actions, a physical manifestation of her despair.

Before: Full or nearly full when Alison began drinking, …
After: Collected as evidence by forensic teams, photographed in …
Before: Full or nearly full when Alison began drinking, now empty and discarded on the table. It may be tipped over or lying on its side, its contents consumed in a short, frantic period.
After: Collected as evidence by forensic teams, photographed in situ, and later analyzed for fingerprints and residue. It becomes part of the toxicology report confirming Alison’s overdose.
Alison's Execution Shotgun

Alison’s execution shotgun is the centerpiece of the crime scene, abandoned on the sink where she left it after firing a fatal blast into the back of Daryl Garrs’ head. The weapon is still warm, its barrel likely smeared with gore, and its presence is a silent testament to the violence that unfolded. Catherine’s eyes linger on it as she radios for backup, her gaze flickering between the shotgun and Alison’s barely conscious form. It is both a clue and a symbol—the physical manifestation of Alison’s desperate, fatal act of love and destruction. Forensic teams will later process it for fingerprints and residue, but in this moment, it is a grotesque relic of the murder-suicide.

Before: Loaded, recently fired, and placed haphazardly on the …
After: Secured as evidence by forensic teams, tagged and …
Before: Loaded, recently fired, and placed haphazardly on the sink after the shooting. The barrel is still warm, and traces of brain matter and blood may be visible on its surface.
After: Secured as evidence by forensic teams, tagged and removed from the scene for analysis. Its condition is documented, and it becomes a key piece of proof in the investigation.
Catherine Cawood's Handheld Police Radio

Catherine’s handheld police radio is her lifeline in the chaos, the device through which she coordinates the response to the crisis. She grips it tightly as she radios for backup, her voice measured but urgent, directing the dispatch of ambulances, forensic teams, and additional officers. The radio crackles with static, a reminder of the institutional machinery now in motion. It is not just a tool—it is a symbol of Catherine’s authority and the system she represents, a bridge between the horror of the scene and the resources needed to address it. Without it, the response would be delayed, and lives could be lost. In this moment, it is the difference between chaos and control.

Before: Attached to Catherine’s belt or holster, fully charged …
After: Still in Catherine’s possession, now slightly warm from …
Before: Attached to Catherine’s belt or holster, fully charged and ready for use. It has been used earlier in the day for routine communications but is now repurposed for an emergency.
After: Still in Catherine’s possession, now slightly warm from use. It has facilitated the dispatch of critical resources, and its log will later be reviewed as part of the investigation.
Far Sunderland Farm Kitchen Table

The kitchen table is the epicenter of the violence, its surface a grotesque canvas of blood, brain matter, and shattered lives. Daryl Garrs’ body is slumped across it, his face pressed into the gore, while Alison sits nearby, her own life ebbing away. The table is not just a piece of furniture—it is a symbol of the Garrs family’s collapse, a stage for their final, tragic act. Catherine’s boots stick slightly to the floor as she steps into the room, her eyes drawn to the table and the horror it holds. It is a detail that will haunt her, a physical manifestation of the case’s escalating brutality. Forensic teams will later process it for trace evidence, but in this moment, it is a silent witness to the murder-suicide.

Before: A ordinary kitchen table, now transformed into a …
After: Cordoned off as part of the crime scene, …
Before: A ordinary kitchen table, now transformed into a crime scene. Its surface is clean but for the blood and gore from Daryl’s shooting, and it bears the weight of Alison’s slumped body.
After: Cordoned off as part of the crime scene, photographed, and processed for forensic evidence. The table becomes a key piece of the investigation, its condition documented in detail.
Shafiq Shah's Baton

Shafiq Shah’s baton is drawn as he heads upstairs to check for additional threats or victims, its rigid form a stark contrast to the chaos of the kitchen. The baton is not used—there are no threats to subdue—but its presence is a reminder of the potential for violence and the need for caution. Shafiq grips it tightly, his knuckles white, as he moves through the upstairs corridors. It is a symbol of his role as a police officer, a tool of control in an uncontrollable situation. While it does not factor into the immediate action, its presence underscores the tension and the unspoken fear of what else they might find.

Before: Holstered at Shafiq’s belt, unused but ready for …
After: Returned to its holster after Shafiq confirms the …
Before: Holstered at Shafiq’s belt, unused but ready for deployment. It is a standard-issue police baton, designed for crowd control and self-defense.
After: Returned to its holster after Shafiq confirms the upstairs is clear. It remains unused, but its presence has served as a psychological anchor in the chaos.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

3
Far Sunderland Farm Kitchen/Dining Room

The kitchen/dining room of Far Sunderland Farm is the epicenter of the horror, a space transformed from a place of domestic routine into a crime scene of unimaginable violence. The walls, ceiling, and door are splattered with blood and brain matter, the table a grotesque altar to the murder-suicide that unfolded. Catherine and Shafiq step into this nightmare, their boots sticking slightly to the floor as they take in the carnage. The room is stifling, the air thick with the metallic scent of blood and the acrid tang of alcohol. It is a place of death, but also of desperate, twisted love—a kitchen where a mother ended her son’s life and then tried to end her own. The location is not just a setting; it is a character in its own right, a silent witness to the unraveling of the Garrs family and the escalating brutality of Tommy Lee Royce’s influence.

Atmosphere Oppressively heavy with the weight of violence and despair. The air is thick with the …
Function The primary crime scene, where the murder-suicide took place. It serves as the stage for …
Symbolism Represents the fragility of the rural Yorkshire family and the destructive power of Tommy Lee …
Access Restricted to Catherine, Shafiq, and later forensic teams. The scene is secured to prevent contamination, …
Blood and brain matter splattered across walls, ceiling, and door Empty vodka and whisky bottles on the table, alongside scattered Diazepam packs The shotgun abandoned on the sink, still warm from use The kitchen table, once a place for meals, now a grotesque centerpiece of violence The metallic scent of blood mixed with the acrid tang of alcohol and gunpowder
Upstairs Corridors/Rooms, Far Sunderland Farm

The upstairs of Far Sunderland Farm is a secondary but critical location in this event, serving as a potential hiding place for additional victims or threats. Shafiq Shah is sent to check it after Catherine assesses the kitchen, his baton drawn as he moves through the corridors. The upstairs is quiet, the heavy silence broken only by the creak of floorboards and the distant crackle of Catherine’s radio. It is a place of tension and uncertainty, where the unknown looms large. While no threats are found, the act of securing the upstairs is a necessary precaution, ensuring that the scene is fully contained before forensic teams arrive. The location is a reminder of the broader instability of the farmhouse and the need for thoroughness in the investigation.

Atmosphere Heavy with anticipation and unease. The air is still, the only sounds the creak of …
Function A secondary crime scene check, ensuring no additional victims or threats remain. It serves as …
Symbolism Represents the unseen dangers lurking in the periphery of the case. While the kitchen is …
Access Initially restricted to Shafiq Shah as he conducts his search. Later, it will be accessed …
Heavy silence broken only by the creak of floorboards Dust motes floating in the dim light filtering through curtains The distant crackle of Catherine’s radio from downstairs Shafiq’s baton drawn and gripped tightly as he moves through the corridors
Far Sunderland Farm Yard

The yard of Far Sunderland Farm serves as the transition point between the horror of the kitchen and the relative safety of the outside world. It is here that Catherine and Shafiq drag Alison Garrs after deciding to prioritize her survival over preserving the crime scene. The yard is bathed in morning sunlight, a stark contrast to the blood-drenched interior. The red Peugeot, dented and scratched, sits as a silent witness to the chaos, its presence a reminder of the Garrs family’s isolation and the violence that has unfolded. The yard is not just a location—it is a threshold, a place where the inside and outside worlds collide, and where the consequences of the murder-suicide begin to unfold.

Atmosphere A surreal mix of pastoral beauty and grim reality. The morning sunlight casts long shadows …
Function The point of extraction and stabilization. It serves as the space where Catherine and Shafiq …
Symbolism Represents the transition from chaos to control, from the private horror of the farmhouse to …
Access Initially restricted to Catherine, Shafiq, and Alison. Later, it will be accessed by medical personnel …
Morning sunlight casting long shadows across the dirt and gravel The red Peugeot, dented and scratched, parked haphazardly in the yard The distant call of birds, a stark contrast to the groans of Alison Garrs The patrol car where Catherine and Shafiq arrived, now a symbol of institutional response

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

3
Hebden Bridge Local Council

The Emergency Medical Services (Ambulance Service) is dispatched to Far Sunderland Farm in response to Catherine’s urgent radio call, tasked with stabilizing Alison Garrs’ condition and transporting her to a hospital for further treatment. Their arrival is a race against time, as Alison’s overdose has left her in a critical state. The paramedics work swiftly to assess her vitals, administer life-saving interventions, and prepare her for transport. Their involvement is not just medical—it is a lifeline, the difference between Alison’s survival and her death. The ambulance service’s role is a reminder of the fragility of life and the importance of rapid response in crises. Without their intervention, Alison would have died at the scene, and a critical piece of the investigation would have been lost.

Representation Through the physical presence of paramedics at the scene, their medical interventions, and their coordination …
Power Dynamics Operating in collaboration with the police but with a primary focus on saving lives. Their …
Impact The ambulance service’s intervention ensures that Alison Garrs survives to potentially provide critical testimony or …
Internal Dynamics The team operates under strict medical protocols, with each member playing a specialized role (e.g., …
Stabilize Alison Garrs’ condition and prevent her death from the overdose. Coordinate with police and forensic teams to ensure that medical interventions do not compromise the crime scene. Administration of emergency medical care (e.g., intravenous fluids, oxygen, antidotes for overdose) Transport of patients to the hospital for further treatment Coordination with other emergency services to ensure a unified response
Rishworth Police Force (Bravo November four-five)

The West Yorkshire Police (represented by Bravo November four-five) play a critical role in this event, serving as the institutional backbone of the response to the crisis at Far Sunderland Farm. Through Catherine’s radio calls, the organization is activated, dispatching ambulances, forensic teams, and additional officers to secure the scene. The radio dispatcher logs the details of the emergency with clinical efficiency, ensuring that the machinery of response is set in motion. The organization’s involvement is not just logistical—it is a lifeline, the difference between chaos and control. Without the police’s rapid response, Alison Garrs would likely have died, and the crime scene would have been compromised. The organization’s power lies in its ability to coordinate resources and ensure that no detail is overlooked, even in the face of unimaginable horror.

Representation Through the disembodied voice of the radio dispatcher and the institutional protocols followed by Catherine …
Power Dynamics Exercising authority over the scene and the individuals involved. The police’s response is decisive and …
Impact The police’s involvement ensures that the scene is processed according to protocol, balancing the need …
Internal Dynamics The chain of command is tested as Catherine makes the morally complex decision to move …
Dispatch critical resources (ambulance, forensic teams, additional officers) to the scene with minimal delay. Log all details of the emergency accurately to ensure a thorough investigation and to comply with procedural requirements. Coordination of resources through radio communication Enforcement of institutional protocols (e.g., securing the scene, preserving evidence) Deployment of specialized teams (forensic, medical, investigative) to address the crisis
Forensic Team (F-Sup) (Evidence Collection)

The Forensic Team (F-Sup) is summoned to Far Sunderland Farm in response to Catherine’s radio call, tasked with processing the blood-drenched kitchen and documenting the murder-suicide. Their arrival marks the transition from crisis management to forensic investigation, as they collect evidence—blood samples, fingerprint analysis, gunshot residue, and toxicology reports—to reconstruct the events that unfolded. The team’s work is methodical and precise, ensuring that every detail is preserved for the investigation. Their involvement is critical not only for solving the case but also for confirming the circumstances of Daryl’s death and Alison’s overdose. Without their expertise, the narrative of what happened in the kitchen would remain incomplete, and the connection to Tommy Lee Royce’s influence might be obscured.

Representation Through their physical presence at the scene, their collection of evidence, and their adherence to …
Power Dynamics Operating under the authority of the police but with specialized expertise that gives them significant …
Impact The forensic team’s work will determine the official narrative of the murder-suicide, influencing the investigation’s …
Internal Dynamics The team operates as a cohesive unit, with each member contributing specialized skills (e.g., fingerprint …
Collect and document forensic evidence to reconstruct the sequence of events leading to the murder-suicide. Preserve the integrity of the crime scene to ensure that all evidence is admissible and accurate. Collection and analysis of physical evidence (blood, fingerprints, gunshot residue, toxicology samples) Documentation of the crime scene through photography, sketches, and detailed notes Adherence to chain-of-custody protocols to ensure evidence integrity

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"CATHERINE: Alison? Alison? Can you hear me? Alison, it’s Catherine Cawood. Sergeant Cawood."
"CATHERINE: Alison, listen love, listen to me - (nothing. CATHERINE turns to SHAF) - I want you to squeeze my hand if you can hear me."
"CATHERINE: (struggling) Man up, Princess. Use your initiative."
"ALISON: (seeing DARYL) Oh - ! (becomes tearful, overwhelmed by the sight of her son's body)"
"CATHERINE: (on radio) Bravo November four-five. Urgent assistance required. Far Sunderland Farm up Wainstalls, on Cold Edge Road. I need an ambulance, there’s a forty-something woman - Alison Garrs - suspected overdose. Diazepam, not sure how many, and it looks like she’s washed ‘em down with vodka and whisky. Her pulse is weak, she’s conscious and breathing. There’s also a male. I’m fairly certain it’s her son, Daryl Garrs. Fatal shotgun injury to the back of his head. Possible weapon at the scene."