Fabula
S2E6 · Happy Valley S02E06

Catherine Prioritizes Life Over Protocol

Catherine Cawood arrives at Far Sunderland Farm to discover a horrific crime scene: Daryl Garrs lies dead from a shotgun wound to the head, while his mother, Alison, has overdosed on a lethal cocktail of alcohol and diazepam. The room is drenched in blood and gore, the shotgun abandoned on the sink. Catherine immediately shifts into crisis mode, first checking Alison’s pulse and attempting to rouse her, then radioing for urgent medical and forensic backup. When Alison begins to stir and shows signs of distress, Catherine defies protocol by physically moving her out of the crime scene—despite Shaf’s objections—prioritizing the woman’s survival over preserving the integrity of the scene. The decision underscores Catherine’s growing desperation to protect the vulnerable, even at the cost of her professional integrity. Alison’s fragmented, tearful reaction to seeing Daryl’s body hints at her involvement in the murder, while Catherine’s sharp, measured radio communication reveals her ability to function under extreme pressure. The scene’s visceral brutality and Catherine’s moral dilemma—between duty and humanity—set the stage for the investigation’s escalation and her personal unraveling as Tommy Lee Royce’s influence tightens its grip.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Catherine attempts to question Alison about who killed Daryl, but Alison is overwhelmed by the sight of Daryl and her failing health. Catherine, recognizing Alison's distress and inability to move, decides to move from the scene despite procedure.

inquiry to frustrated urgency

Shaf questions Catherine's decision to move Alison, citing procedure, but Catherine impatiently orders him to help her. As Shaf assists, Catherine sarcastically relays a message over the radio, and they both get Alison out from the crime scene.

impatience to determined action

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

5

A state of dissociative horror, oscillating between numbness and overwhelming grief. Her emotional state is one of shattered denial—she is acutely aware of what she’s done but unable to process it rationally, her body and mind both failing her in the aftermath of the murder-suicide attempt.

Alison Garrs is found slumped at the table, barely conscious, her face streaked with tears and her eyes bloodshot. She is disoriented, her body barely functional, and her mind flooded with guilt and horror upon seeing Daryl’s corpse. She attempts to flee the room but is physically and mentally incapacitated, reduced to tearful, incoherent reactions. Her gurgling noises and eventual cry of ‘Oh—!’ upon seeing Daryl’s body reveal the depth of her trauma and complicity in the act.

Goals in this moment
  • Escape the immediate horror of the scene, even if her body won’t cooperate.
  • Avoid confronting the reality of Daryl’s death and her role in it, though her traumatized reactions betray her guilt.
Active beliefs
  • She believed killing Daryl was the only way to protect him—or herself—from further suffering or exposure.
  • Her overdose attempt was a desperate, failed escape from the consequences of her actions.
Character traits
Physically and mentally broken Overwhelmed by guilt and grief Incapable of coherent communication or action Visibly traumatized by the sight of Daryl’s death
Follow Alison Garrs's journey

Steely professionalism masking deep shock and compassionate desperation. Her surface calm belies a visceral reaction to the carnage, particularly in her uncharacteristic profanity and the way her eyes linger on the shotgun—a moment of rare vulnerability in her otherwise unshakable demeanor.

Catherine Cawood steps into the blood-drenched kitchen and immediately assesses the scene with tactical precision. She checks Alison Garrs’ pulse, attempts to rouse her, and radios for urgent medical and forensic backup, all while navigating the grotesque details of Daryl’s shotgun death. Despite the horror, she maintains measured professionalism, though her sharp rebuke to Shafiq—‘fucking get on with it’—reveals her fraying composure. Her decision to move Alison out of the crime scene, defying protocol, underscores her prioritization of human life over procedural integrity, a choice that reflects her growing moral conflict in the face of Tommy Lee Royce’s escalating threat.

Goals in this moment
  • Save Alison Garrs’ life at all costs, even if it means compromising crime scene integrity.
  • Secure the scene and initiate a full investigative response to uncover what happened, while ensuring no additional threats remain.
Active beliefs
  • Human life must be prioritized over procedural perfection, especially when the victim is already traumatized.
  • The scene’s horror suggests a personal, desperate act—Alison’s involvement is likely, and Catherine’s instincts drive her to protect her rather than treat her as a suspect immediately.
Character traits
Tactical precision under pressure Compassionate urgency Protocol-defying decisiveness Dark humor in crisis (e.g., radioing Clegg about ‘tea and biscuits’) Emotionally guarded but visibly shaken by the scene’s brutality
Follow Catherine Cawood's journey
Supporting 2

Neutral and procedural. The dispatcher’s emotional state is one of clinical detachment, focused solely on transmitting and logging information without reaction to the grim details of the scene.

The Radio Dispatcher (Bravo November four-five) serves as the detached, procedural voice of the police institution. They log Catherine’s urgent requests with calm efficiency, confirming receipt of details about the overdose, fatal shotgun wound, and need for forensic and medical backup. Their role is purely logistical, acting as a conduit between Catherine and the broader investigative machine without emotional involvement.

Goals in this moment
  • Ensure all requested resources (ambulance, forensic team, detectives) are dispatched to the scene promptly.
  • Maintain accurate logs of the incident for investigative and administrative purposes.
Active beliefs
  • Their role is to facilitate the response, not to question or interpret the circumstances.
  • Catherine’s authority as a senior officer must be deferred to without hesitation.
Character traits
Detached professionalism Efficient and unemotional Reliable institutional conduit No personal reaction to the horror described
Follow Radio Dispatcher's journey

Hesitant but resolute. Shafiq is visibly overwhelmed by the scene’s brutality, though he channels his discomfort into action. His emotional state is one of dutiful compliance mixed with quiet unease, particularly when Catherine snaps at him—a rare moment of friction between them.

Shafiq Shah follows Catherine’s lead with dutiful efficiency, initially checking upstairs for additional victims or threats with his baton drawn. He returns to find Catherine already in crisis mode, attempting to move Alison. His hesitation—‘I thought you weren’t supposed to move [people]’—highlights his adherence to protocol, but he ultimately complies with Catherine’s urgent directive, helping to drag Alison outside. His role is secondary but critical, providing backup and reinforcing Catherine’s authority even as he questions her methods.

Goals in this moment
  • Ensure the scene is secure and no additional threats exist, as directed by Catherine.
  • Support Catherine’s efforts to save Alison, despite his misgivings about moving her.
Active beliefs
  • Protocol exists to preserve evidence and protect investigations, but Catherine’s experience often overrides it in life-or-death situations.
  • Catherine’s judgment is usually sound, even when it defies standard procedure.
Character traits
Dutiful and rule-following Quick to follow orders but hesitant in morally ambiguous situations Physically capable but emotionally reserved in high-stress scenarios Loyal to Catherine, even when her actions challenge protocol
Follow Shafiq Shah …'s journey
Clegg

Councillor Clegg is mentioned indirectly as the recipient of a darkly ironic notification about Alison and Daryl’s absence from the …

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

7
Alison Garrs' Diazepam Packs

The 30 empty diazepam blister packs are scattered in front of Alison, a stark visual representation of her overdose. Their emptiness is a brutal detail, emphasizing the lethality of her attempt. The packs are not just evidence but a narrative device, highlighting the medical precision of her self-destruction. Catherine notes their presence immediately, understanding that this was no accidental overdose but a deliberate, desperate act. The packs’ empty compartments are a silent scream, a final, futile attempt to escape the horror of what she had done.

Before: Scattered across the table in front of Alison, …
After: Photographed, collected, and logged as evidence. The forensic …
Before: Scattered across the table in front of Alison, all pills removed from the blister packs. Some packs are crumpled, suggesting haste or desperation in their consumption.
After: Photographed, collected, and logged as evidence. The forensic team counts the remaining pills (if any) and notes the absence of pills in the blister packs for the toxicology report.
Shafiq Shah's Baton

Shafiq Shah’s baton is drawn as he checks the upstairs for additional threats, a precautionary measure in the face of the unknown. The baton is a symbol of his role as a police officer—ready to defend or restrain if necessary. While it is not used in this specific event, its presence underscores the tension and potential for further violence. The baton is a functional tool but also a narrative device, reinforcing the idea that this scene is not yet fully contained and that danger may still lurk in the shadows of the farmhouse.

Before: Attached to Shafiq’s belt, fully extended and ready …
After: Retracted and reattached to Shafiq’s belt after he …
Before: Attached to Shafiq’s belt, fully extended and ready for use. The baton’s surface is clean, and it has not been deployed in this scene.
After: Retracted and reattached to Shafiq’s belt after he confirms the upstairs is clear. The baton remains unused but is a constant reminder of the potential for physical confrontation.
Alison Garrs' Overdose Evidence (Whisky Bottle and Diazepam Tablets)

The empty whisky bottle complements the vodka bottle as another piece of the overdose puzzle. Its presence on the table, alongside the diazepam packs, creates a tableau of self-destruction. The whisky’s stronger alcohol content suggests Alison’s intent was not just to numb herself but to ensure her overdose would be fatal. The bottle’s emptiness is a chilling detail, reinforcing the scene’s atmosphere of irreversible despair. For Catherine, it is a clue that deepens the tragedy—Alison did not act impulsively but with a grim, calculated finality.

Before: Empty, placed near the vodka bottle and diazepam …
After: Photographed in situ, then collected as evidence. The …
Before: Empty, placed near the vodka bottle and diazepam packs on the kitchen table. The bottle’s rim is smudged with lipstick, and a few drops of whisky have spilled onto the table, mixing with the blood.
After: Photographed in situ, then collected as evidence. The forensic team swabs the table for residue and logs the bottle’s contents (or lack thereof) as part of the toxicology report.
Alison Garrs' Overdose Evidence Vodka Bottle

The empty vodka bottle sits in front of Alison Garrs, a grim testament to her overdose attempt. It is one of several objects—alongside the whisky bottle and diazepam packs—that paint a picture of her desperate, self-destructive final moments. The bottle’s emptiness is a silent accusation, its glass surface catching the light as Catherine’s eyes scan the table. It is not just a clue but a narrative device, underscoring the depth of Alison’s despair and the lengths she went to escape the consequences of her actions.

Before: Empty, placed directly in front of Alison at …
After: Collected as evidence by the forensic team, sealed …
Before: Empty, placed directly in front of Alison at the kitchen table, surrounded by other overdose paraphernalia. The bottle’s label is smudged with fingerprints, and a faint scent of alcohol mixes with the metallic tang of blood in the air.
After: Collected as evidence by the forensic team, sealed in a plastic bag, and logged as part of the overdose investigation. The table’s surface is swabbed for residue, and the bottle’s contents (or lack thereof) are noted in the report.
Alison's Execution Shotgun

Alison’s execution shotgun is the centerpiece of the crime scene’s horror, abandoned on the sink after being used to blast Daryl’s head apart. Its presence is a silent witness to the violence, its gore-smeared surface a stark contrast to the domestic setting of the kitchen. Catherine’s eyes linger on it, a visceral reminder of the brutality that unfolded. The shotgun is not just a weapon but a symbol of Alison’s desperate, final act—a tool of execution that now serves as critical forensic evidence.

Before: Loaded and recently fired, lying on the sink …
After: Secured as evidence by the forensic team, bagged …
Before: Loaded and recently fired, lying on the sink with blood and brain matter splattered across its surface and the surrounding area. The barrel is still warm, and the scent of gunpowder lingers in the air.
After: Secured as evidence by the forensic team, bagged and tagged for analysis. The sink area remains cordoned off as part of the crime scene, with the shotgun’s exact position photographed and documented.
Catherine Cawood's Handheld Police Radio

Catherine’s handheld police radio is her lifeline in the chaos, the tool through which she coordinates the response. She uses it to call for an ambulance, forensic backup, and additional officers, her voice measured despite the horror around her. The radio is not just a communication device but a symbol of her professionalism under pressure. Its static-filled responses from the dispatcher ground the scene in reality, reinforcing that this is an active police investigation, not just a personal tragedy. The radio’s role is functional but also narrative, as it highlights Catherine’s dual role as both a police officer and a human being grappling with the scene’s emotional weight.

Before: Clipped to Catherine’s belt or held in her …
After: Used throughout the scene to relay updates and …
Before: Clipped to Catherine’s belt or held in her hand, fully charged and operational. The radio’s display shows active channels, and the speaker emits occasional static.
After: Used throughout the scene to relay updates and requests. After the initial chaos, it remains on Catherine’s person as she continues to direct the response, its battery level slightly drained from extended use.
Far Sunderland Farm Kitchen Table

The kitchen table is the epicenter of the crime scene, its surface drenched in blood and brain matter from Daryl’s shotgun wound. It serves as both a literal and symbolic stage for the horror that unfolded: a place where a mother and son’s twisted relationship reached its violent climax. The table’s gore-splattered state is a visceral reminder of the act’s brutality, and its centrality in the room forces Catherine to confront the scene’s reality head-on. The table is not just a piece of furniture but a narrative device, anchoring the audience’s gaze and emphasizing the irrevocability of the violence.

Before: Covered in blood, brains, and other organic matter …
After: Cordoned off as part of the crime scene, …
Before: Covered in blood, brains, and other organic matter from Daryl’s fatal shotgun wound. The table’s wooden surface is stained, and the legs are splattered with gore. A few shards of bone or teeth may be embedded in the wood.
After: Cordoned off as part of the crime scene, with forensic markers placed around Daryl’s body and the splatter patterns. The table is photographed, swabbed, and sampled for evidence, and the body is removed for autopsy.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

3
Far Sunderland Farm Kitchen/Dining Room

The kitchen/dining room of Far Sunderland Farm is the primary setting for this event, a space transformed from a domestic hub into a crime scene of unimaginable horror. The room’s usual functions—preparing meals, sharing conversations—are perverted by the violence that took place here. The blood-drenched table, the gore-splattered walls, and the abandoned shotgun create an atmosphere of irreversible despair. The kitchen is not just a location but a character in its own right, its domestic familiarity rendered grotesque by the act of murder-suicide. The room’s confined space amplifies the claustrophobic tension, forcing Catherine and Shafiq to navigate the horror in close quarters.

Atmosphere Oppressively claustrophobic, with a metallic tang of blood and the acrid scent of gunpowder. The …
Function Crime scene and site of moral reckoning. The kitchen serves as the stage for the …
Symbolism Represents the collapse of domestic stability and the irrevocable nature of violence. The kitchen, a …
Access Restricted to police personnel and emergency responders. The scene is secured by Shafiq and later …
Blood and brain matter splattered across walls, ceiling, and door, creating a grotesque pattern of violence. The shotgun abandoned on the sink, its barrel still warm and the scent of gunpowder lingering in the air. Empty alcohol bottles and diazepam packs scattered on the table, evidence of Alison’s overdose attempt. Daryl’s body slumped forward on the table, his head obliterated by the shotgun blast, creating a macabre centerpiece to the scene. The dim, natural light filtering through the windows, casting long shadows that accentuate the gore and the stillness of the room.
Far Sunderland Farm Yard

The yard of Far Sunderland Farm serves as the temporary safe zone where Catherine and Shafiq drag Alison’s barely conscious body after removing her from the crime scene. The yard is a transitional space, a place where the horror of the kitchen is momentarily left behind, though its weight lingers. The open air and natural light provide a stark contrast to the confined, gore-drenched interior, offering a brief respite before the full investigative machine arrives. The yard is not just a location but a narrative device, symbolizing the thin line between chaos and control, between life and death.

Atmosphere Open and exposed, with the morning sun casting long shadows across the dirt and gravel. …
Function Temporary refuge and staging area for medical and police response. The yard allows Catherine and …
Symbolism Represents the fragile boundary between the world of the living and the world of the …
Access Initially restricted to Catherine, Shafiq, and Alison. Later, it becomes a hub of activity as …
The red Peugeot with its dented front driver’s side, a silent witness to the chaos that unfolded inside the farmhouse. The crunch of gravel underfoot as Catherine and Shafiq drag Alison’s limp body toward the open space. The distant wail of sirens growing louder, a promise of help but also a reminder of the institutional machinery that will soon descend on the scene. The morning sun casting a golden light on the yard, a stark contrast to the darkness of the kitchen.
Upstairs Corridors/Rooms, Far Sunderland Farm

The upstairs of Far Sunderland Farm is a secondary location in this event, serving as a space that must be secured to ensure no additional threats or victims exist. Shafiq Shah checks the upstairs with his baton drawn, his movements tense and cautious. The upstairs is not the primary focus of the horror but functions as a narrative device, reinforcing the idea that the violence could have spread beyond the kitchen. Its emptiness is a relief, allowing Catherine and Shafiq to focus their efforts on Alison and the crime scene below. The upstairs also symbolizes the unseen and unknown—what other secrets might the farmhouse hold?

Atmosphere Heavy with silence and the creaking of old floorboards. The air is stale, and the …
Function Secondary crime scene check and threat assessment. The upstairs must be cleared to ensure the …
Symbolism Represents the unseen and the unknown—what other horrors might lurk in the shadows of this …
Access Initially restricted to Shafiq Shah as he conducts his sweep. Later, it is secured by …
Dust motes floating in the dim light, highlighting the stillness of the air. The creaking of floorboards under Shafiq’s weight, amplifying the tension of his search. Closed doors and drawn curtains, creating an atmosphere of secrecy and isolation. The faint scent of mildew or old wood, a reminder of the farmhouse’s age and neglect.

Organizations Involved

Institutional presence and influence

3
Hebden Bridge Local Council

The Emergency Medical Services (Ambulance Service) are critical to this event, as they are summoned to save Alison Garrs’ life. Their role is to provide immediate medical treatment, stabilize her condition, and transport her to a hospital for further care. The ambulance service is not physically present in this event but is invoked through Catherine’s radio call, their arrival imminent. Their involvement is a direct response to the medical emergency, ensuring that Alison does not die from her overdose despite the horrors she has inflicted upon herself and her son.

Representation Through Catherine’s urgent radio call, which requests an ambulance for Alison Garrs. Their absence in …
Power Dynamics Operating under the authority of the police and medical protocols. The ambulance service’s power lies …
Impact The ambulance service’s involvement ensures that Alison Garrs survives her overdose, allowing her to face …
Stabilize Alison Garrs’ condition and prevent her from dying from the overdose. Transport her to a hospital for further medical treatment and monitoring. Providing on-site medical care, including administering antidotes, monitoring vital signs, and ensuring airway stability. Coordinating with the police to ensure that Alison’s transport does not compromise the crime scene further than it already has. Working in conjunction with hospitals to ensure that Alison receives the necessary follow-up care.
Rishworth Police Force (Bravo November four-five)

The Police (Bravo November four-five) are the institutional backbone of this event, responding to Catherine’s urgent radio calls with dispatch and efficiency. Their role is to mobilize the necessary resources—ambulance, forensic team, detectives, and additional officers—to secure the scene and begin the investigation. The police organization is not physically present in the kitchen but is represented through the radio dispatcher, who logs Catherine’s requests and coordinates the response. Their involvement is critical, as it ensures that the chaos of the crime scene is contained and that the investigative process begins immediately.

Representation Through the radio dispatcher, who serves as the voice of the police institution. The dispatcher’s …
Power Dynamics Exercising authority over the scene and the individuals involved. The police organization holds the power …
Impact The police organization’s involvement ensures that the crime scene is treated as a priority, with …
Ensure the immediate safety of all individuals involved, including the barely conscious Alison Garrs. Secure the crime scene to preserve evidence and prevent contamination, despite Catherine’s decision to move Alison. Dispatching emergency resources (ambulance, forensic team, detectives) to the scene based on Catherine’s requests. Coordinating with local council officials (e.g., Councillor Clegg) to notify them of disruptions, even in the midst of a crisis. Maintaining logs and records of the incident for administrative and investigative purposes.
Forensic Team (F-Sup) (Evidence Collection)

The Forensic Team (F-Sup) is summoned to Far Sunderland Farm to process the crime scene, collecting evidence that will be critical to understanding what transpired. Their role is to document the gore-splattered kitchen, the shotgun, the empty alcohol bottles, and the diazepam packs, ensuring that every detail is preserved for the investigation. The forensic team is not physically present in this event but is invoked through Catherine’s radio call, their arrival imminent. Their involvement is essential, as it ensures that the scene is treated as a criminal investigation rather than just a medical emergency.

Representation Through Catherine’s radio call, which directs the forensic team to ‘prove’ the scene. Their absence …
Power Dynamics Operating under the authority of the police investigation. The forensic team’s power lies in their …
Impact The forensic team’s work will be pivotal in determining the legal and narrative outcome of …
Collect and preserve all physical evidence from the crime scene, including the shotgun, alcohol bottles, diazepam packs, and blood samples. Document the scene in detail, including photographs, sketches, and notes, to ensure a comprehensive record for the investigation. Using scientific methods to analyze evidence, such as blood spatter patterns, toxicology reports, and fingerprint analysis. Providing objective, unbiased data that will be used to reconstruct the events leading up to Daryl’s death and Alison’s overdose. Working in conjunction with the police to ensure that the evidence supports the investigative narrative.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"CATHERINE: Alison? Alison? Can you hear me? Alison, it’s Catherine Cawood. Sergeant Cawood."
"CATHERINE: Alison, listen love, listen to me - (nothing. CATHERINE turns to SHAF) I want you to squeeze my hand if you can hear me."
"CATHERINE: (struggling) Man up, Princess. Use your initiative."
"ALISON: (seeing DARYL) Oh - ! (becomes tearful, overwhelmed by the sight of her son’s body)"