Fabula
S2E5 · Happy Valley S02E05

Alison’s lethal deception of Daryl

Alison lures Daryl into a false sense of security by proposing an elaborate escape plan to America, painting a vivid picture of their shared fantasy—Las Vegas, Disneyland, and the Golden Gate Bridge—while he remains oblivious to her true intentions. As she details their itinerary, she slips into the next room, retrieves a shotgun, and returns to point it at the back of his head, maintaining a calm, maternal facade throughout. The abrupt shift from warmth to lethal threat underscores the irreversible collapse of their trust, exposing Alison’s calculated ruthlessness and the depth of her desperation to protect herself from the consequences of Daryl’s crimes. The moment serves as both a turning point in their relationship and a foreshadowing of the violent escalation to come, where maternal love curdles into lethal pragmatism.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

2

Alison retrieves a shotgun from the next room while Daryl expresses his excitement about travelling to Disneyland.

excited to tense

Alison returns, pointing the shotgun at the back of Daryl's head while continuing to calmly discuss their fantasy trip to America and Disneyland.

hopeful to dread

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

2

A detached, almost clinical calm, as if she has already grieved and accepted the necessity of what she is about to do. The warmth in her voice when she returns to the kitchen is a performance, a final act of love before the violence.

Alison’s off-screen actions in the next room are the pivotal moment of the event. She moves with quiet purpose, her hands steady as she picks up the old shotgun, her breath controlled. The act of retrieving the weapon is methodical, devoid of hesitation, as if she has rehearsed it in her mind a hundred times. The shotgun becomes an extension of her resolve, a tool to sever the last thread of their fractured bond. Her silence in this moment is louder than any word she has spoken.

Goals in this moment
  • To ensure the shotgun is ready and that her aim is true, leaving no room for failure or hesitation.
  • To return to the kitchen before Daryl suspects anything, maintaining the deception until the moment of the act.
Active beliefs
  • That this is the only way to protect what remains of their family and her own sanity.
  • That Daryl, in his current state, is beyond redemption and that her actions are a mercy.
Character traits
Resolute in desperation Silently lethal Methodical in execution Emotionally numb to the act Physically precise
Follow Alison Garrs's journey

Euphoric and trusting, masking deep-seated insecurity and fear of abandonment. His excitement is tinged with a child’s desperation for approval, unaware of the violence lurking behind Alison’s words.

Daryl sits at the kitchen table, engrossed in Alison’s fabricated escape plan, his face alight with childlike excitement as he rattles off destinations—Las Vegas, Florida, California—oblivious to the shotgun now pressed against the back of his head. His questions about feeding the sheep and hiring bicycles reveal his fragile trust in Alison’s promises, his emotional state teetering between hope and vulnerability. Physically, he remains seated, his back to Alison, unaware of the lethal shift in her demeanor as she maintains a maternal facade.

Goals in this moment
  • To believe in the escape plan and the promise of a new life in America, free from his crimes and isolation.
  • To cling to the fantasy of adventure and family bonding, using it as a shield against the reality of his actions and the consequences looming over him.
Active beliefs
  • That Alison’s love for him is unconditional and would never allow harm to come to him, despite his crimes.
  • That the escape plan is real and that he deserves a second chance, fueled by his childlike optimism and fear of prison.
Character traits
Naively hopeful Emotionally dependent Childlike in imagination Vulnerable to manipulation Oblivious to danger
Follow Daryl Garrs's journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

9
Alison Garrs' Deceptive Passports

The passports, like the money, are a deceptive prop in Alison’s performance, used to sell the illusion of their escape. She describes them as ready and waiting, detailing the trips they will take—Las Vegas, Disneyland, San Francisco—as if they were real. Daryl, eager and trusting, buys into the fantasy, his excitement a stark contrast to the shotgun Alison soon retrieves. The passports are never shown; they exist only in her words, a cruel tease that deepens the betrayal. Their role is to reinforce the lie, to make the escape feel imminent and real, lulling Daryl into a false sense of security before the violence.

Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, …
After: Revealed as a fabrication, their absence underscoring the …
Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, part of the elaborate lie she weaves to keep Daryl compliant.
After: Revealed as a fabrication, their absence underscoring the hollow nature of Alison’s promises. The passports’ nonexistence is a bitter irony, as Daryl’s hopes are shattered by the shotgun’s cold reality.
Alison's Execution Shotgun

The old shotgun is the silent catalyst of the event, transitioning from a relic of farm life to the instrument of Alison’s lethal deception. Initially, it lies unused in the next room, its presence unknown to Daryl as Alison spins her escape fantasy. When she retrieves it, the weapon becomes a physical manifestation of her resolve, its cold steel a stark contrast to the warmth of her voice. As she returns to the kitchen, the shotgun is pressed against the back of Daryl’s head, its barrel an unspoken threat that underscores the irreversible shift in their relationship. The object’s role is purely functional—it is the tool that will end Daryl’s life—but its narrative weight is immense, symbolizing the collapse of trust and the finality of Alison’s choice.

Before: Stored in the next room, unused and unnoticed, …
After: Fully loaded and pressed against Daryl’s head, its …
Before: Stored in the next room, unused and unnoticed, part of the farm’s utilitarian clutter. Its condition is functional but aged, reflecting the Garrs’ isolated and deteriorating circumstances.
After: Fully loaded and pressed against Daryl’s head, its presence now the dominant force in the room. The shotgun remains in Alison’s grip, its role in the event complete but its aftermath yet to unfold.
Alison's Fabricated Savings Claim

Alison’s fabricated couple thousand pounds serve as a verbal prop in her deception, a tangible lie that lowers Daryl’s defenses. She describes the money as if it were real, detailing how it will fund their escape to America—Las Vegas, Disneyland, San Francisco—while Daryl, oblivious, latches onto the promise. The money is never physically shown; it exists only in her words, a cruel illusion that contrasts sharply with the shotgun she retrieves. Its role is to distract and manipulate, to give Daryl a fleeting sense of hope before the violence erupts. The object’s power lies in its absence—it is a ghost of possibility, haunting the moment with what could have been.

Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, …
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the …
Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, part of the elaborate lie she weaves to keep Daryl compliant.
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the hollow nature of Alison’s promises. The money’s nonexistence is a bitter irony, as Daryl’s hopes are shattered by the shotgun’s cold reality.
Alison's Fictional Aeroplane

The aeroplane to America is the culmination of Alison’s deception, the final piece of her fabricated escape plan. She describes it as the vehicle that will take them to Las Vegas, Disneyland, and San Francisco, painting a vivid picture of freedom and adventure. Daryl, his eyes alight with childlike excitement, clings to the idea, his questions about Disneyland revealing his desperation for the fantasy to be real. The aeroplane, like the other deceptive props, is never seen; it exists only in Alison’s words, a cruel tease that deepens the betrayal. Its role is to reinforce the lie, to make the escape feel within reach before the shotgun shatters the illusion. The aeroplane’s nonexistence is a poignant symbol of the dreams that will never come to pass.

Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, …
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the …
Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, part of the elaborate lie she weaves to keep Daryl compliant.
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the hollow nature of Alison’s promises. The aeroplane’s nonexistence is a bitter irony, as Daryl’s hopes are shattered by the shotgun’s cold reality.
Alison's Planned Taxi from Sunderland Farm

The planned taxi from Sunderland Farm is another layer in Alison’s deception, a logistical detail meant to ground her lie in reality. She describes calling the taxi as the first step in their escape, painting a picture of it arriving to whisk them away to Manchester and, ultimately, America. Daryl, caught up in the fantasy, nods along, his questions about feeding the sheep and the logistics of their trip revealing his trust in her plan. The taxi, like the money and passports, is never seen; it exists only in Alison’s words, a verbal prop that adds to the illusion of their impending adventure. Its role is to make the escape feel plausible, to distract Daryl from the truth: that the only journey he will take is the one ending in the kitchen.

Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, …
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the …
Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, part of the elaborate lie she weaves to keep Daryl compliant.
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the hollow nature of Alison’s promises. The taxi’s nonexistence is a bitter irony, as Daryl’s hopes are shattered by the shotgun’s cold reality.
Alison's Sketched Train Route to Manchester

The train to Manchester is a critical piece of Alison’s fabricated itinerary, a detail that adds credibility to her escape plan. She describes it as the next leg of their journey, the step that will take them from the farm to the airport and, ultimately, to America. Daryl, eager and hopeful, engages with the detail, asking about the sheep and the flights, his excitement revealing his investment in the lie. The train, like the other deceptive props, is never seen; it exists only in Alison’s words, a verbal construct that lulls Daryl into a false sense of security. Its role is to sell the fantasy, to make the escape feel like a real, achievable goal before the violence erupts.

Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, …
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the …
Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, part of the elaborate lie she weaves to keep Daryl compliant.
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the hollow nature of Alison’s promises. The train’s nonexistence is a bitter irony, as Daryl’s hopes are shattered by the shotgun’s cold reality.
Ferry Past Alcatraz in Alison's Escape Fantasy

The ferry past Alcatraz is a darkly ironic detail in Alison’s deception, a touch of exoticism meant to appeal to Daryl’s sense of adventure. She describes the ferry ride as part of their trip to San Francisco, painting a picture of gliding past the infamous island prison. Daryl, eager and hopeful, reacts with excitement, his questions revealing his trust in her plan. The ferry, like the other deceptive props, is never seen; it exists only in Alison’s words, a verbal construct that adds to the illusion of their escape. Its role is to sell the fantasy, to make the trip feel real and exciting before the shotgun shatters the dream. The ferry’s nonexistence is a cruel irony, as Daryl’s hopes are dashed by the violence that follows.

Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, …
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the …
Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, part of the elaborate lie she weaves to keep Daryl compliant.
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the hollow nature of Alison’s promises. The ferry’s nonexistence is a bitter irony, as Daryl’s hopes are shattered by the shotgun’s cold reality.
Rental Car in Nevada

The rental car in Nevada is an early detail in Alison’s fabricated escape plan, a logistical touchpoint meant to ground her lie in reality. She describes hiring the car as the first step in their American adventure, painting a picture of driving through the desert to Las Vegas and beyond. Daryl, caught up in the fantasy, reacts with enthusiasm, his excitement revealing his investment in the lie. The car, like the other deceptive props, is never seen; it exists only in Alison’s words, a verbal construct that adds to the illusion of their trip. Its role is to make the escape feel plausible, to distract Daryl from the truth: that the only journey he will take is the one ending in the kitchen. The car’s nonexistence is a poignant reminder of the freedom he will never experience.

Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, …
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the …
Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, part of the elaborate lie she weaves to keep Daryl compliant.
After: Revealed as a fabrication, its absence underscoring the hollow nature of Alison’s promises. The car’s nonexistence is a bitter irony, as Daryl’s hopes are shattered by the shotgun’s cold reality.
Rented Bicycles for Golden Gate Bridge

The rented bicycles for the Golden Gate Bridge are a whimsical detail in Alison’s deception, a touch of fantasy meant to appeal to Daryl’s childlike imagination. She describes hiring the bicycles as part of their trip to San Francisco, evoking images of cycling across the iconic bridge with the bay breeze in their hair. Daryl, caught up in the moment, reacts with enthusiasm, his excitement revealing his investment in the lie. The bicycles, like the other deceptive props, are never seen; they exist only in Alison’s words, a verbal construct that adds to the illusion of their adventure. Their role is to distract and manipulate, to give Daryl a fleeting sense of joy before the violence erupts. The bicycles’ nonexistence is a poignant reminder of the dreams that will never be realized.

Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, …
After: Revealed as a fabrication, their absence underscoring the …
Before: Nonexistent; purely a verbal construct in Alison’s deception, part of the elaborate lie she weaves to keep Daryl compliant.
After: Revealed as a fabrication, their absence underscoring the hollow nature of Alison’s promises. The bicycles’ nonexistence is a bitter irony, as Daryl’s hopes are shattered by the shotgun’s cold reality.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

2
Far Sunderland Farm Kitchen/Dining Room

The kitchen/dining room at Far Sunderland Farm is the epicenter of Alison’s deception, where the illusion of a shared escape plan is woven and ultimately shattered. The space, once a place of shared meals and fragile intimacy, becomes the stage for a performance of maternal love that masks lethal intent. The table, set with a plate of bacon and eggs, tea, and toast, symbolizes the domestic facade that Alison maintains even as she plans Daryl’s death. The room’s tight quarters and the morning light filtering through the windows create a sense of intimacy that contrasts sharply with the violence to come. As Alison returns from the next room with the shotgun, the kitchen transforms into a battleground, where the weight of Daryl’s crimes and Alison’s desperation hang heavier than the weapon itself.

Atmosphere Stifling and tense, with the warmth of the breakfast meal contrasting sharply with the cold …
Function Primary site of deception and betrayal, where Alison’s performance of maternal love reaches its climax. …
Symbolism Represents the death of trust and the collapse of the Garrs’ fragile world. The kitchen, …
Access The kitchen is accessible to both Alison and Daryl, but the next room—where Alison retrieves …
The plate of bacon and eggs, now growing cold as the deception unfolds. The shotgun’s barrel pressed against the back of Daryl’s head, a silent threat that looms over the room. The ticking of Alison’s watch, a countdown to the inevitable violence. The morning light casting long shadows across the table, mirroring the moral ambiguity of the moment. The distant sound of sheep bleating, a reminder of the life Daryl will never return to.
Far Sunderland Farm – Side Room (Shotgun Retrieval)

The next room at Far Sunderland Farm is the staging area for Alison’s lethal act, a space of utilitarian clutter where the shotgun is retrieved in secret. Its tight quarters and the morning light filtering through the doorway create a sense of urgency, as Alison moves with deliberate calm to pick up the weapon. The room’s functional role is to enable her swift return to the kitchen, where she can point the gun at Daryl’s head without arousing suspicion. The next room’s isolation from the kitchen ensures that Daryl remains oblivious to her true intentions, allowing the deception to unfold uninterrupted. The space is a metaphor for the hidden layers of Alison’s psyche, where her maternal love and lethal pragmatism coexist in uneasy tension.

Atmosphere Tense and utilitarian, with the morning light cutting shadows across the cluttered space. The air …
Function Preparation space for Alison’s lethal act, where the shotgun is retrieved in secret. The room’s …
Symbolism Represents the hidden layers of Alison’s psyche, where her maternal love and lethal pragmatism coexist. …
Access The next room is off-limits to Daryl during the event, as Alison retrieves the shotgun …
The old shotgun, lying among farm tools, its presence a silent threat. The morning light filtering through the doorway, casting long shadows that mirror Alison’s moral ambiguity. The utilitarian clutter of the room, reflecting the Garrs’ isolated and deteriorating circumstances. The sound of Alison’s steady breath as she picks up the weapon, a stark contrast to the chaos of her emotions. The doorway leading back to the kitchen, a threshold between deception and violence.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

No narrative connections mapped yet

This event is currently isolated in the narrative graph


Key Dialogue

"ALISON: I’ve got a plan. DARYL: Have you? ALISON: You’ve always wanted to go to America. Haven’t you?"
"ALISON: (in the next room, ALISON has prepared an old shotgun. She picks it up carefully) ALISON: (ALISON comes back into the room, behind DARYL. She points the gun as steadily as she can at the back of his head.) Yeah. If I pay her. Then you get the ferry back. Past Alcatraz."
"ALISON: Course we can love."