Fabula
S2E5 · The Mirror and the Light Episode 5

The Rubies of Anne Boleyn: Cromwell’s Paranoid Purge of Catherine Howard

In the Long Gallery of Hampton Court, Thomas Cromwell—already on edge from the specter of Anne Boleyn’s downfall—stumbles upon a dress-fitting for the new Queen’s Maids-of-Honour. His unease deepens when Norfolk arrives with his niece, Catherine Howard, a young, vacuous beauty adorned in rubies once worn by Anne Boleyn. The sight triggers Cromwell’s paranoia: the court’s history of female influence over Henry VIII is a minefield, and Catherine’s presence—especially in Anne’s jewels—feels like a deliberate provocation. When Lady Rochford casually notes the rubies’ provenance, Cromwell’s reaction is visceral. He orders Rochford to remove Catherine from court until Henry’s marriage to Anne of Cleves is legally secured, a move that reveals his strategic caution and lingering fear of female intrigue. The tension escalates as Wriothesley interrupts with urgent news, forcing Cromwell to abandon his confrontation—leaving Catherine’s fate (and his own) precariously unresolved. This moment foreshadows the court’s volatile power dynamics, where even a young woman’s attire can symbolize political threat, and underscores Cromwell’s dwindling authority as Henry’s displeasure with Anne of Cleves looms.

Plot Beats

The narrative micro-steps within this event

1

Cromwell, disturbed by the presence of Catherine Howard and the reminder of Anne Boleyn, orders Lady Rochford to send Catherine away until the King is safely married.

annoyance to command

Who Was There

Characters present in this moment

9

Amused and provocative, enjoying the tension she stirs between Cromwell and the Howards, while masking her own resentments.

Lady Rochford engages in sarcastic commentary, drawing attention to Catherine Howard’s rubies and their connection to Anne Boleyn. She mocks Cromwell’s age and the Maids-of-Honour’s attire, while also revealing personal details about Catherine—such as her lack of a mother and her naivety. Her provocations are calculated, aiming to unsettle Cromwell and highlight the court’s volatile dynamics.

Goals in this moment
  • To provoke Cromwell by highlighting Catherine’s connection to Anne Boleyn’s rubies, reinforcing his paranoia.
  • To assert her own influence by exposing the court’s secrets and vulnerabilities.
Active beliefs
  • Cromwell’s authority is fragile, and exposing his fears will weaken his position.
  • The court thrives on intrigue, and her role is to navigate and exploit it.
Character traits
Sarcastic Provocative Observant Amused by court intrigue Strategically indiscreet
Follow Jane Rochford's journey

Uneasy and alarmed, masking deep paranoia about the court’s history of female intrigue and his own precarious position.

Cromwell enters the Long Gallery during a dress-fitting for the Maids-of-Honour, initially intending to leave but drawn back by Lady Rochford’s provocation. His attention is immediately seized by Catherine Howard’s presence, particularly her rubies—once Anne Boleyn’s—which trigger a visceral reaction. He orders Lady Rochford to remove Catherine from court, revealing his paranoia about female influence and his strategic caution. His authority is abruptly interrupted by Wriothesley’s urgent summons, forcing him to exit without resolving the confrontation.

Goals in this moment
  • To neutralize potential threats to Henry’s marriage by removing Catherine Howard from court.
  • To assert his authority over Lady Rochford and the Howards, despite his growing unease.
Active beliefs
  • Female influence at court is inherently destabilizing, as demonstrated by Anne Boleyn’s downfall.
  • His political survival depends on controlling Henry’s environment, even if it means clashing with powerful nobles like Norfolk.
Character traits
Paranoid Authoritative Strategic Viscerally reactive Politically cautious
Follow Thomas Cromwell's journey

Proud and distracted, masking his strategic satisfaction with Catherine’s potential as a pawn in his political games.

Norfolk arrives with Catherine Howard on his arm, displaying unusual pride in her presence. He ignores her attempts to regain his attention, instead watching for the King’s arrival. His brief explanation of the Maids-of-Honour’s role is distracted, as his focus remains on the political dynamics unfolding around him. His satisfaction with Catherine’s presence is tinged with calculation, reflecting his strategic maneuvering in the court.

Goals in this moment
  • To position Catherine Howard as a potential influence over Henry VIII, countering Cromwell’s authority.
  • To assert his family’s dominance in the court by leveraging Catherine’s youth and beauty.
Active beliefs
  • Female beauty and youth are powerful tools in securing royal favor.
  • Cromwell’s influence is waning, and the Howards must seize the opportunity to regain power.
Character traits
Proud Distracted Politically calculating Strategic Dismissive of female attention
Follow Thomas Howard, …'s journey

Excited and oblivious, unaware of the political tensions her presence ignites, but clearly thrilled by the court’s grandeur.

Catherine Howard arrives with Norfolk, displaying excited awe and a vacant expression. She pulls impatiently at Norfolk’s arm, asks naive questions about the Maids-of-Honour, and admires their attire. Her adornment in Anne Boleyn’s rubies draws Cromwell’s attention, though she remains oblivious to the political significance of her presence. Her excitement is childlike, contrasting sharply with the court’s intrigue.

Goals in this moment
  • To gain Norfolk’s attention and understand her role in the court.
  • To impress the Maids-of-Honour and embrace her new position.
Active beliefs
  • Her beauty and youth will naturally secure her a place in the court.
  • The court’s intrigue is beyond her understanding, and she is merely an observer.
Character traits
Excited Naive Oblivious Childlike Easily distracted
Follow Catherine Howard's journey
Supporting 5

Reserved and composed, engaged in the ritual of the dress-fitting without awareness of the broader intrigue.

Maid-of-Honour 2 receives a compliment from another Maid-of-Honour during the dress-fitting. Her participation is minimal but contributes to the court’s social dynamics. Like the other maids, she is focused on the aesthetic and ceremonial aspects of her role, providing a backdrop to the political tensions.

Goals in this moment
  • To ensure her attire meets the court’s standards.
  • To fulfill her role as a Maid-of-Honour with dignity.
Active beliefs
  • Her primary duty is to the Queen and the court’s traditions.
  • Political maneuvering is not her concern.
Character traits
Reserved Polite Dutiful Peripheral to conflict
Follow Maid-of-Honour 2's journey

Composed and pleased with her appearance, unaware of the political undercurrents.

Maid-of-Honour 3 participates in the dress-fitting, complimenting her own gown. Her focus is on the aesthetic details of her attire, reflecting the court’s emphasis on appearance and ceremony. Her role is largely ceremonial, providing a contrast to the political maneuvering of the other characters.

Goals in this moment
  • To ensure her gown is flawless for the upcoming events.
  • To uphold the court’s standards of beauty and ceremony.
Active beliefs
  • Her role is to embody the court’s ideals of beauty and grace.
  • Political conflicts are irrelevant to her duties.
Character traits
Self-assured Focused on aesthetics Peripheral to intrigue Dutiful
Follow Maid-of-Honour 3's journey

Alarmed and urgent, reflecting the high-stakes nature of the news he brings and the precariousness of Cromwell’s position.

Wriothesley appears abruptly, looking alarmed, and interrupts Cromwell’s confrontation with Lady Rochford. His urgent demeanor suggests critical news, prompting Cromwell to follow him out of the Long Gallery. His interruption underscores the volatility of the court and the constant demands on Cromwell’s attention.

Goals in this moment
  • To deliver urgent news to Cromwell, prioritizing his duties over the confrontation.
  • To ensure Cromwell’s attention is directed to the most critical matters at hand.
Active beliefs
  • Cromwell’s authority is essential to the stability of the court, and his focus must be protected.
  • The court’s intrigue is relentless, and even minor distractions can have serious consequences.
Character traits
Alarmed Urgent Discreet Loyal Efficient
Follow Thomas Wriothesley …'s journey

Polite and composed, unaware of the deeper political currents swirling around her.

Maid-of-Honour 1 participates in the dress-fitting, complimenting another Maid-of-Honour’s attire. Her focus remains on the aesthetic details of the fitting, providing a contrast to the political tension unfolding around her. Her role is peripheral but contributes to the court’s bustling atmosphere.

Goals in this moment
  • To ensure the Maids-of-Honour’s attire is perfect for the upcoming events.
  • To maintain the court’s protocols and rituals.
Active beliefs
  • Her role is to support the Queen and uphold the court’s traditions.
  • Political intrigue is beyond her purview, and she focuses on her duties.
Character traits
Polite Observant of aesthetics Peripheral to intrigue Focused on duty
Follow Anne of …'s journey

Neutral and focused, performing their duties without awareness of the political tensions around them.

Female Servants adjust the matching white attire of the Maids-of-Honour during the dress-fitting. Their work is methodical and unobtrusive, ensuring the Maids’ gowns are perfect. Their presence underscores the court’s reliance on a vast network of servants to maintain its rituals and appearances.

Goals in this moment
  • To ensure the Maids-of-Honour’s attire is flawless.
  • To maintain the court’s standards of presentation.
Active beliefs
  • Their role is to serve the court and its rituals without question.
  • Political intrigue is beyond their concern.
Character traits
Dutiful Unobtrusive Methodical Focused on service
Follow Female Servants …'s journey

Objects Involved

Significant items in this scene

2
Anne Boleyn's Rubies

Anne Boleyn’s rubies, adorning Catherine Howard’s neck, serve as a potent symbolic artifact that triggers Cromwell’s paranoia. Their presence is a deliberate provocation, evoking the court’s volatile history of female influence over Henry VIII. Lady Rochford’s pointed remark about their provenance—‘did they not once belong to Anne Boleyn’—amplifies their significance, turning a piece of jewelry into a political weapon. The rubies symbolize the court’s cyclical nature and the ever-present threat of female intrigue, which Cromwell fears could destabilize his carefully constructed alliances.

Before: Possessed by Catherine Howard, worn as part of …
After: Remain with Catherine Howard, though her presence in …
Before: Possessed by Catherine Howard, worn as part of her attire, drawing Cromwell’s immediate attention.
After: Remain with Catherine Howard, though her presence in court is temporarily removed, leaving their symbolic threat unresolved.
Cloth from the Old Dowager’s Wardrobe (Speculative Fabric Source)

The cloth from the old dowager’s wardrobe, referenced by Lady Rochford, is implied to be part of Catherine Howard’s dress. Its mention serves as a subtle dig at Cromwell, suggesting that her attire—and by extension, her court position—may not be as legitimate or modest as it appears. The cloth’s provenance becomes a point of contention, reinforcing the idea that Catherine’s presence is strategically orchestrated by the Howards to undermine Cromwell’s influence. Its role is symbolic, representing the court’s layers of deception and the manipulation of appearances.

Before: Unseen but implied to be part of Catherine …
After: Remains part of Catherine Howard’s attire, though her …
Before: Unseen but implied to be part of Catherine Howard’s dress, its origin questioned by Lady Rochford.
After: Remains part of Catherine Howard’s attire, though her removal from court temporarily neutralizes its political significance.

Location Details

Places and their significance in this event

1
Hampton Court Palace

The Long Gallery at Hampton Court Palace serves as a neutral yet charged ground for this confrontation. Its elongated space, filled with the chatter and rustle of the Maids-of-Honour’s dress-fitting, contrasts sharply with the political tension that erupts when Cromwell arrives. The gallery’s grandeur and formality provide a stage for the court’s rituals, but it also becomes a battleground for power struggles. The presence of mirrors and pins during the fitting underscores the court’s obsession with appearance and control, while the gallery’s openness allows for eavesdropping and public displays of authority—such as Cromwell’s order to remove Catherine Howard.

Atmosphere Tension-filled with whispered conversations and the rustle of fabrics, the gallery’s usual frivolity is disrupted …
Function Neutral ground for public confrontations and political maneuvering, where court rituals and power struggles intersect.
Symbolism Represents the court’s dual nature: a space of beauty and ceremony that is also a …
Access Open to court members and servants, but the political dynamics limit who can freely participate …
The chatter and laughter of the Maids-of-Honour, creating a contrast to the political tension. Mirrors and pins used during the dress-fitting, symbolizing the court’s focus on appearance and control. The elongated space of the gallery, amplifying the sense of exposure and public scrutiny.

Narrative Connections

How this event relates to others in the story

What this causes 6
Causal

"Cromwell's order to send Catherine away is ignored, resulting in her presence at court during Anne's arrival and highlighting Cromwell's decreasing authority."

Cromwell’s Authority Fractures: Catherine’s Defiance and Gardiner’s Triumph
S2E5 · The Mirror and the Light …
Causal

"Cromwell's order to send Catherine away is ignored, resulting in her presence at court during Anne's arrival and highlighting Cromwell's decreasing authority."

The King’s Triumph, Cromwell’s Undoing: A Court of Vultures
S2E5 · The Mirror and the Light …
Foreshadowing medium

"Catherine Howard's presence, wearing rubies that once belonged to Anne Boleyn, foreshadows her role as the next queen and Cromwell's impending downfall, mirroring Anne Boleyn's fall from grace."

The King’s Unraveling: Cromwell’s Last Warning
S2E5 · The Mirror and the Light …
Foreshadowing medium

"Catherine Howard's presence, wearing rubies that once belonged to Anne Boleyn, foreshadows her role as the next queen and Cromwell's impending downfall, mirroring Anne Boleyn's fall from grace."

The Hollow Crown and the Fall: Cromwell’s Arrest and Stripping of Power
S2E5 · The Mirror and the Light …
Foreshadowing medium

"Cromwell orders Lady Rochford to dismiss Catherine, but Catherine appears among the Queen's Maids of Honour. This foreshadows Henry's interest in Catherine and Cromwell's undoing."

Cromwell’s Authority Fractures: Catherine’s Defiance and Gardiner’s Triumph
S2E5 · The Mirror and the Light …
Foreshadowing medium

"Cromwell orders Lady Rochford to dismiss Catherine, but Catherine appears among the Queen's Maids of Honour. This foreshadows Henry's interest in Catherine and Cromwell's undoing."

The King’s Triumph, Cromwell’s Undoing: A Court of Vultures
S2E5 · The Mirror and the Light …

Key Dialogue

"**LADY ROCHFORD**: *And those rubies—did they not once belong to Anne Boleyn.* **CROMWELL**: *Send her away.*"
"**CROMWELL**: *I think we’ve had enough of Norfolk’s nieces.* **LADY ROCHFORD**: *Well, I sent her back because she looks twelve. But they swear she is of sufficient age, and here she is again.*"
"**CROMWELL**: *Say what you like. Just make sure she doesn’t show her face here again until the King is safely married.*"